Essays · For recruiting firms
Recruiting has optimized everything except the candidate.
As a former CFO and CRO, my career has largely revolved around three things: growing revenue, improving margins, and building exceptional teams.
In recruiting, I see a massive, untapped opportunity.
If you can increase the probability of placing the candidates you already have, you can grow revenue without proportionately increasing the cost of sourcing talent.
Recruiting firms have invested heavily in technology to source, screen, and match talent. But what’s always confounded me is how little they have invested in making that talent easier to place.
Qualified doesn’t mean prepared
Having interviewed and hired people across every function within a company, I’ve seen exceptionally qualified candidates struggle to communicate what they’re capable of.
There are three things candidates particularly struggle with:
- Quantifying the business impact of their work.
- Demonstrating judgment beyond their technical capabilities.
- Maintaining clarity and composure under pressure.
None of these are necessarily indicative of someone’s ability to do the job. But they absolutely influence how a hiring manager assesses their ability.
For a recruiter compensated on successful placements, this creates an interesting problem. You’ve identified a qualified candidate, established a relationship with them, secured an interview, and now a meaningful portion of your potential revenue is dependent on how effectively that person communicates during a relatively short conversation.
Why wouldn’t you want to improve their ability to do so?
Historically, providing high-quality, personalized interview coaching at scale has been difficult. Recruiters have limited time, and coaching someone effectively requires experience, judgment, and repeated practice. Sending a candidate a job description and a document containing common interview questions only gets them so far.
Rejection is another opportunity
I think there’s an equally interesting, and potentially much larger, opportunity with candidates who aren’t placed.
Consider how much time and money recruiting firms invest in building relationships with candidates who ultimately don’t generate revenue.
Maybe the client went with someone else. Maybe the position was eliminated. Maybe the candidate wasn’t quite ready for the role. Regardless of the reason, the recruiter has already invested in establishing that relationship.
Instead of concluding the interaction with a generic rejection email, imagine giving that candidate access to tools that help them understand their capabilities, develop professionally, and better prepare for future opportunities.
What if that person could have stronger skills, a clearer understanding of their professional value, and a greater ability to communicate it. And what if we could do that within days?
Bullhorn’s 2026 GRID Talent Trends Report found that:
- 95% of candidates offered reskilling opportunities indicated they would continue working with their recruiter.
- 91% of candidates receiving at least weekly communication indicated they would continue working with their recruiter.
Separately, Bullhorn’s 2026 Industry Trends Report found that 40% of top-performing recruiting firms were expanding into candidate reskilling.
The industry is beginning to recognize the commercial value of investing in candidates beyond an individual placement. I think there’s considerable room to take this further.
The economics are compelling
Let’s assume a recruiting firm facilitates 100 candidate interviews per month and earns an average placement fee of $20,000.
Consider what happens as interview-to-placement conversion improves.
| Conversion rate | Monthly placements | Monthly revenue | Annual revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20% | 20 | $400,000 | $4.8M |
| 22% | 22 | $440,000 | $5.3M |
| 25% | 25 | $500,000 | $6M |
| 30% | 30 | $600,000 | $7.2M |
A five-percentage-point improvement in conversion translates into $1.2 million in incremental annual revenue. Same interview volume. Same average placement fee. Same underlying candidate pool.
These numbers are illustrative, not projected results. But the business logic is straightforward. And because you’ve already incurred much of the cost of sourcing, screening, and securing interviews for these candidates, the incremental revenue could carry attractive margins.
If I were running a recruiting firm, I’d be extremely interested in understanding how much of that conversion rate I could influence.
Your candidate database should appreciate in value
I would think about a candidate database less as a static inventory of resumes and more as a portfolio of professional relationships with varying degrees of future revenue potential.
The people in that database aren’t static. Their skills, experience, responsibilities, compensation, and professional ambitions are constantly evolving.
A candidate you couldn’t place two years ago might be exactly the person your highest-value client needs today.
Rather than periodically reaching out to see if someone is looking for a new job, I’d want my firm actively contributing to that person’s professional development between placements.
Over time, the objective would be to build a candidate pool that is:
- Better prepared for client interviews.
- More articulate about their capabilities and business impact.
- More engaged with and loyal to the firm.
Your candidate database should compound in value over time, not simply grow in size.
Why we built Winsly
Winsly is an AI career advisor built around the systems and methodologies I developed throughout my executive career.
Winsly helps professionals understand their value, develop their capabilities, and master high-stakes career conversations through AI-powered coaching and realistic simulations.
For recruiting firms, I’d start by integrating Winsly into two existing candidate interactions:
- Before an interview: Give candidates access to realistic interview simulations, executive-level feedback, and personalized preparation grounded in their actual professional experience.
- After an unsuccessful placement: Give candidates something that continues to provide value long after the recruiting process ends, regardless of why they weren’t selected.
Neither requires recruiters to become full-time career coaches. And both create an opportunity to improve the economics of relationships the firm has already invested in building.
I’d measure interview-to-placement conversion, candidate re-engagement, subsequent placements, and the incremental revenue generated relative to the cost of providing the tools.
The incentives are unusually well aligned. Candidates get better career support. Recruiters can provide more value without proportionately increasing their workload. Recruiting firms have an opportunity to generate more revenue. Employers get better-prepared candidates.
You don’t necessarily need a bigger candidate pool to build a bigger recruiting business. You might just need to invest more intelligently in the one you already have.
Run a recruiting firm? Tell us about it.
We’ll write back about trying Winsly with your candidates: before their interviews, after one isn’t placed, or both.
Or try the interview practice yourself: Start 7 days free
More essays
Forget the ladder. Build your ramp.
Why Winsly exists: 10 promotions in 12 years, and the log behind them.
3 min read
How to choose a company that accelerates your career
The hard NOs, the hard YESs, and the question to ask before any offer.
2 min read
How to find a boss who will accelerate your growth
Early on, your boss matters more than the company. How to tell an accelerator from a ceiling.
2 min read